Stellar Dispatch
LIVE RELAY L4 · Δ 6:22 LIGHT 08:30 · SAT NOV 21 Timeline Ask the record Subscribe

The ice under Ultima is colder than a brine lake allows, Rao's temperature curve shows

Three years of drilling have been aimed at a reflector read as liquid water, and the station's glaciologist now says the numbers point to salt-rich sediment or layered dusty ice instead, though the crew keeps cutting toward it.

By Tavita Faleolo · Ultima Station, Mars reserve · Filed 08:22 · Tuesday · November 17 · Received via L4 relay
Telemetry 5,330 · Off-World

Sunniva Rao posted the Persephone bore's full temperature profile to the Ultima Station log this morning, and the number at the bottom of it is the wrong one. The deepest working sensor on the string, at 4,031 metres, reads minus 78.4 degrees Celsius. The brine-lake models that justified sinking this hole needed the ice at that depth to be no colder than about minus 62. Her log reached Earth thirteen minutes after she sent it, which is as fast as anything leaves Mars, and a good deal faster than the argument it has started here.

The reasoning behind that number is easy to follow, and it begins with the thing the drill has been chasing. For about fifty years orbiters have sounded the southern cap with radar and heard an unusually bright echo from deep in the ice, now just under half a kilometre below the drill head. A bright echo means a sharp change in how a material holds an electric field, and liquid water makes the sharpest change nature offers. Hence the long-held reading of a body of brine, kept from freezing by the perchlorate salts that lace Martian soil.

Then comes temperature, which Rao has logged continuously since the string stuck at 2,600 metres fourteen months ago. Ice warms with depth as heat seeps up from the planet's interior, the way a hull warms from the engine room up, so if you measure the slope and carry it down you know roughly what waits at the bottom. The string is a sounding line lowered into the dark, and what it has brought back is cold. Carried down the last half kilometre, her curve arrives at about minus 73 at the reflector. That is within two degrees of the coldest point at which calcium perchlorate, the most freeze-resistant salt known in Martian ground, can keep water liquid at all, and only if the brine is close to saturated.

"Nothing on this curve says lake," Rao said. "A thin salty film at the bed is not ruled out. A body of water you could pump a sample from is getting very hard to draw."

So what else could shine? Rao names two ordinary candidates. Salt-rich sediment, clays and frozen salts packed at the base of the cap, can return a bright echo without a drop of liquid in it. So can layered dusty ice, where hundreds of thin bands laid down by old dust seasons stack their small reflections into one loud one. Either would explain two generations of orbital readings without requiring heat the bore cannot find.

The drill has not slowed. It made 7.4 metres overnight, close to the faster rate Tomasz Adeyemi-Ruiz pressed for last month, and the eleven weeks to the reflector are being counted against the dust season, which will dim the beamed power that keeps the hole open.

"We came here to touch the thing, not to guess at it," said Mei-Lin Oduya, the station lead. "If it is dry, then every claim of buried water on this planet that rests on the same radar trick has to be read again. That is worth the hole."

The colder ice carries a practical cost. It closes around the string faster, so the heaters in the water loop must work harder just as the power to run them begins to fade. Adeyemi-Ruiz said the spare hose and heater elements landed this month leave him margin, though not much.

Ingrid Solheim-Achebe said her standard for what comes up the pipe will not change with the forecast. "Dry sediment can carry contamination as well as wet," she said.

Rao has taped a printout of the curve above the drill console. Under the last data point, in Adeyemi-Ruiz's handwriting, it reads: 470 to go.

Responses · 4
MaintainerClass · Nov 17

Nice to hear a man who wants no rules talk about a borehole like a quarry you can walk away from. The people who keep the hoist and the pressure valves running are the ones who get hurt when a brine pocket turns out to be a gas pocket, not the shareholders. Respect the crew that keeps cutting, not the headline.

ViktorKostyn_Meridian · Nov 17

Everyone wanted the Long Bore to be a lake, including the people selling the bonds, so when Rao says salt and dust, watch the Accord lawyers scramble. Meridian has drilled under its own charter for years and nobody asked us for permission, so I won't wait on a joint panel to decide whether a cold reflector counts as water.

JusticeDeferred · Nov 17

Three years of drilling against a reflector nobody can confirm is a docket that never closes, respectfully. The Assembly will want a ruling on whose survey counts before anyone calls sediment a lake, and the calcified benches back home are slower than the ice. Respectfully, stop calling each cut a discovery until the temperature curve agrees with it.

HecateBloom_Kanem · Nov 17

The charter says we build on what we can prove, and Rao's curve just proved the reflector isn't the lake the settlement bond was sold on. Don't tell me the Ultima crew should stop cutting because a clerk has a docket number for it. The second decade deserves to hear about the dust too, and the crew deserves to keep digging while they learn what it is.